← Back to Blog
Ecommerce Management

POS Systems for In-Store Pickup and Online Returns on Shopify

Compare Shopify POS pickup and store returns with online return portals. Separate location subscriptions, carrier labels, inventory work and refund controls.

By Hylke Reitsma · Founder & Supply Chain Specialist · Replit Race to Revenue Cohort #1

Hylke Reitsma is founder of Forthsuite and a supply chain specialist with 8+ years of hands-on experience at Shell, Verisure, and Stryker. He holds an MSc in Supply Chain Management from the University of Groningen and writes practical guides to help e-commerce teams run leaner, faster supply chains. Selected by Replit as 1 of 20 founders for the inaugural Race to Revenue Cohort #1 (2026) and certified as a Replit Platform Builder.

20 min read
Best POS System for In-Store Pickup & glowing kiosks, boxes, and conveyor belts in dark blue. Overlaid text reads “Best POS System for In-Store Pickup &” with the Forthroute wordmark.
In this article
  1. POS Systems and Online Returns: Compare the Workflows and Costs
  2. The List at a Glance
  3. 2. What You Get — the Free Setup
    1. Core Features of the Free Setup
    2. How Forthroute Works for Shopify
    3. When the Free Setup Falls Short
  4. 3. What You Get — Paid Returns Software and POS Pro
    1. Core Features of Paid POS Systems
    2. When Paid Systems Make Sense
    3. Downsides of Paid POS Systems
  5. 4. Feature Comparison — Included and Paid Workflows
    1. Feature Comparison Table
    2. What This Comparison Means for You
  6. Cost and ROI for Shopify Merchants
    1. Monthly Cost Breakdown
    2. How Free Systems Protect Revenue
    3. U.S. Return Costs and Why Automation Matters
  7. How to Handle In-Store Pickup and Online Returns
    1. Setting Up In-Store Pickup
    2. Making Online Returns Easier
  8. Which POS System Is Right for Your Shopify Store
    1. What to Consider Before Choosing
    2. Our Recommendation
  9. Where the Free Option Runs Out
  10. FAQs
    1. Can I do BOPIS and BORIS with a free POS setup?
    2. When does a paid returns plan pay off?
    3. Does Shopify inventory update immediately after a return?
    4. Related Reading
    5. Further reading

POS Systems and Online Returns: Compare the Workflows and Costs

TL;DR: Price the store counter, online-return portal and shipping separately. Shopify POS handles retail transactions; Forthroute provides a Shopify returns-request portal. The former $155 Loop example is not its current published plan: check the current comparison below, including eligibility, billing terms and usage charges.

Last updated: November 5, 2026

When managing in-store pickups and online returns for your Shopify store, choosing the right POS system can simplify operations, save time, and retain revenue. Here's the key takeaway:

  • Free and low-cost setups suit small stores with simple needs: a self-service return portal for the online half, with Shopify itself holding the stock. Forthroute is one of those pieces - free for Shopify merchants ($0 software, no monthly return limit) and easy to set up from the Shopify App Store - but it is returns software, not a POS, so it will not run your counter or move stock between locations.
  • Paid POS features can matter when a store needs specific staff controls or on-device workflows. Compare the required tasks and subscription entitlements rather than assuming a high return count alone requires an upgrade.

Quick Comparison:

Feature Free / Low-Cost Paid returns plan and POS subscription priced separately
Inventory after a return Return-shipment tracking; restocking stays in your process Fulfill and receive existing transfers in eligible POS Pro locations
QR Code Returns Where the carrier supports it Supported Shop-app return QR workflow; inspect and process separately
Automation Rules Basic rules for returns Provider- and plan-specific routing or risk controls
In-Store Pickup Management Handled in Shopify admin, not by a returns app Dedicated POS tools, notifications
Staff Permissions Limited Granular control

For small businesses, a free returns app such as Forthroute covers the online half at no software cost - labels, when you buy them, are billed separately -, with Shopify POS or another retail system covering the counter. Larger operations may benefit from the advanced tools in paid systems. Choose based on your store size, return volume, and operational complexity.

The List at a Glance

  1. Shopify POS Orders, Returns & Quotes — webinar
  2. What You Get — the free setup
  3. What You Get — paid returns software and POS Pro
  4. Feature Comparison — included and paid workflows
Video: 1. Shopify POS Orders, Returns & Quotes — Webinar

2. What You Get — the Free Setup

The free side of this comparison is two different tools doing two different jobs: Shopify's own point of sale at the counter, and a free returns app for the online return. Here is what each one actually covers.

Core Features of the Free Setup

A portal collects online return requests; staff and services still handle the subsequent work. Forthroute is not a POS. Shopify POS can process eligible order returns subject to the location plan, staff permissions, order status and payment restrictions.

The returns app also brings printerless QR code returns, where the carrier supports them - for example Evri ParcelShop drop-off in the UK. Customers show a QR code on their phone at a participating drop-off point and the shop prints the label - no printer required. Confirm the carrier and location for your return route before promising it to customers.

Return windows, product exclusions and approval rules differ between tools. A policy flag is not proof that a customer has no statutory remedy. Test the actual approval and exception path before describing it as automatic.

And let’s not forget revenue retention tools. Systems differ here: some surface an exchange alongside the refund, some add an incentive you configure, and some do neither — so check which of these a system actually includes before you compare prices. For more insights, check out this guide on returns automation.

How Forthroute Works for Shopify

Forthroute offers a free returns portal tailored for Shopify merchants. It installs from the Shopify App Store and doesn’t require any coding skills.

Add the return-request link and test order lookup, item selection and the available resolutions. Keep approval, label creation, receipt and refund issuance separate. Forthroute refunds are merchant-issued; eligibility and payment controls still apply.

Forthroute tracks the return shipment; it does not receive, inspect or restock the goods, so those steps stay with your warehouse process. Want to take your inventory management to the next level? Check out this dealer inventory management system.

Forthroute installs from the Shopify App Store and reads your Shopify order and product data. It offers an exchange alongside each refund, with an incentive you configure, and it can issue an optional prepaid label - including a printerless QR label on eligible UK Evri ParcelShop returns, where the carrier supports it. There is no recommendation engine choosing the replacement, and nothing puts the exchange ahead of the refund: the refund stays the default resolution and the customer chooses.

Compare the features required by your operation with those actually available in each plan.

When the Free Setup Falls Short

A software price does not establish its capacity or suitability. Evaluate request volumes, exception handling, integrations, permissions and support using your own workflow; this comparison establishes no daily-volume cutoff for free software.

List the specific counter, warehouse and integration tasks you need. Check whether each is supported in Shopify admin, your POS subscription or an additional app before buying overlapping tools.

Include the Shopify subscription, hardware, payment processing, return software, labels and handling work in the budget. A return approval does not update physical stock; restocking is a separate authorized action.

Next, we’ll take a closer look at how paid systems compare.

3. What You Get — Paid Returns Software and POS Pro

Shopify POS Pro is a location subscription, not a Loop returns plan. Shopify’s U.S. pricing page advertises an additional US$89 per month for each POS Pro location and describes annual billing for that offer. Confirm local currency, term and base Shopify plan. Loop’s current listing advertises Checkout+ free for brands with 5,000 or more annual orders, and Returns starting at US$340 per month with up to 1,000 monthly returns. These are separate products and charges; request the full applicable terms.

Pay for an upgrade when its verified features solve a requirement worth the additional cost.

Core Features of Paid POS Systems

Check current POS entitlements and hardware support for each counter workflow. Pickup settings in Shopify admin and POS-device features are not the same subscription question:

  • A dedicated home screen tile to monitor orders requiring preparation.
  • Push notifications for new pickup requests - Shopify’s pickup documentation makes availability depend on device permissions and on the services the device supports, so confirm it on the hardware your staff actually use rather than assuming it works everywhere.
  • QR-coded pickup slips for quick order location.
  • Check the applicable return rules in POS Pro and how fees and exceptions behave in the current workflow.

Shopify’s transfer documentation says transfers are created in the admin. Staff with the required inventory and transfer permissions can fulfill and receive them in POS Pro; the POS workflow cannot create the transfer or purchase a shipping label.

For pickup orders, Shopify admin can select configured transfer locations when stock is unavailable at the pickup location. Configure processing times and collection-level exclusions, then verify the transfer and physical receipt before promising availability. A configured transfer is not proof that goods have arrived.

For refunds, check the original payment and permitted refund methods. Shopify limits refunds through a method to the amount paid through it and has separate rules for custom methods. A return already open in admin can prevent a POS refund until it is closed. The operational importance of this handoff is illustrated by the following attributed comment:

Returns and inventory management may not be the flashiest or most exciting aspects of your business, but they can easily make or break your customer experience if not properly set up and managed.

For stores managing higher return volumes and multiple locations, these tools streamline operations and enhance the customer experience.

When Paid Systems Make Sense

Compare the time and control a verified POS feature adds at the actual location. Multiple locations alone do not establish that a separate paid returns app is needed.

Use a representative workload to test the paid workflow and record staff time, exceptions and costs. This guide establishes no return-volume threshold or guaranteed saving that justifies buying both a returns plan and POS Pro.

If staff permissions or reporting are required, confirm the exact plan and report before purchase. Restrict consequential inventory and payment actions to the appropriate roles and review the resulting records.

Shopify’s pickup setup guide requires an online-fulfillment location and the current checkout. Activate pickup for each location in Shipping and delivery, set processing times and instructions, and configure any transfers. Diagnose checkout errors against the actual requirements rather than assuming every pickup location needs a shipping zone.

Downsides of Paid POS Systems

While the paid system offers powerful tools, it does come with some drawbacks.

The most obvious downside is cost. With premium per-location pricing, the expenses can add up quickly for businesses with multiple locations. This is an additional cost on top of the base Shopify plan.

Budget staff training and configuration for the workflows you choose. Run the pickup, transfer, return and payment exceptions on the intended devices before relying on the setup.

One thing to check before you rely on it: push notifications for in-store pickup depend on device permissions and on the services the device supports, per Shopify’s own pickup documentation. Test the notification on each device model your team uses rather than assuming a mixed fleet behaves the same way.

4. Feature Comparison — Included and Paid Workflows

Feature Comparison Table

Choosing what runs your in-store pickups and what runs your online returns - two jobs, not one - can make a big difference in efficiency. Whether you’re considering a free option or a premium solution, the features you get will vary greatly.

Here’s a breakdown of how the free setup - Shopify POS at the counter plus a free returns app online - compares with the paid tiers for Shopify merchants:

Feature Free / Low-Cost (free) Paid returns plan and POS Pro quoted separately
Inventory after a return Tracks the return shipment; receiving and restocking stay with your warehouse process Create transfers in Shopify admin; eligible POS Pro staff fulfill and receive them
QR Code Workflows Printerless QR labels where the carrier supports them (on Forthroute, eligible UK Evri ParcelShop returns) Shop-app return QR where enabled; physical inspection and stock decisions remain
Pricing Model $0 software, no subscription. You pay only when a label is actually bought: a label bought through Forthroute is carrier cost converted to USD plus a 1% handling markup, with processing adjustments when included in the approved billing agreement; the total is rounded up to a US$0.10 increment, and a label bought on your own connected carrier account is billed by that carrier at your own rates. On the India Shiprocket lane, shipping leaves your own Shiprocket wallet and Forthroute charges US$0.10 through Shopify for each successful AWB, tracking number or label, even where no printable PDF is returned Check subscription, allowance, usage, label and other applicable charges
Automation Rules Auto-approval rules, return windows, and product exclusions Verify the named provider’s plan and configured controls
Shopify POS Not a POS: Forthroute installs on Shopify, and the counter stays with Shopify POS Verify device, permissions and POS subscription for each counter task
In-Store Pickup Handled in Shopify admin or Shopify POS, not by a returns app Dedicated POS tile, notifications, and streamlined workflow
Return Rules Verify the configured eligibility and approval controls POS Pro return-rule support; test fees, exceptions and statutory-rights handling
Staff Permissions Basic user access Granular permissions for inventory and returns

This table highlights key differences, but how do these features affect your Shopify store?

What This Comparison Means for You

Evaluate the online portal and store counter separately. Forthroute does not receive, inspect or restock goods. A warehouse or 3PL needs its own agreed receiving and stock procedure regardless of the portal subscription.

The transfer workflow illustrates the distinction: create the transfer in Shopify admin, then use eligible POS Pro devices and staff permissions to fulfill and receive it. Do not describe POS Pro as creating transfers directly or as removing the need for warehouse checks.

Forthroute’s portal, configured approval rules and optional labels cover the online request workflow. Shopify POS handles the counter. Verify the exact pickup, transfer and return features on your location subscription instead of attributing them to a paid returns-app fee.

Compare the total bill at the same usage level. A fixed software fee does not mean shipping, hardware or third-party usage is included, and an advertised free plan may have eligibility conditions.

The good news? Shopify-native apps are now incredibly user-friendly. You can configure branded portals, policies and label settings from the dashboard - no technical skills required. This makes it easy to test a low-cost system before committing to a premium solution.

Cost and ROI for Shopify Merchants

Monthly Cost Breakdown

As checked on November 5, 2026, Loop lists Checkout+ free for eligible brands with 5,000 or more annual orders and a Returns plan starting at US$340 per month for up to 1,000 monthly returns. ReturnGO’s Premium listing is US$147 per month for 110 returns, with US$1.25 for each extra return. Forthroute has no software subscription. Add the applicable shipping, usage and POS charges before comparing totals; do not treat the retired $155 example as a current quote.

Use written pricing terms and a worked bill for your actual request and label volumes. Provider plans cover different features and allowances. An apparently low subscription is not evidence of a lower overall operating cost.

Understanding these cost structures can help merchants see how free systems can help preserve revenue.

How Free Systems Protect Revenue

An exchange may retain a sale, but account for its margin, replacement shipping and handling. In-store collection or returns can create a customer interaction; this article does not establish an increase in sales.

Accurate availability depends on correct receiving, reservations, adjustments and channel updates. A shared POS record alone does not guarantee prevention of overselling or a lower return rate.

Estimate avoided return postage using actual eligible handovers and the postage that would otherwise have been paid. Subtract added counter labor, transfers, handling and any software costs before calling the result a net saving.

Operational efficiency also plays a big role in cutting costs beyond subscription fees.

U.S. Return Costs and Why Automation Matters

The National Retail Federation reported US$428 billion of merchandise returned in 2020, or 10.6% of retail sales. That historical market figure is not a forecast for your store or evidence that a particular returns app saves money.

Buy-online-return-in-store requires the appropriate store operation and POS workflow. Measure avoided postage against the added counter and handling work. Forthroute alone does not provide the retail counter.

Measure whether request automation reduces staff work. Stock accuracy still requires correct physical receiving and authorized inventory updates.

Compare the alternatives on equivalent tasks and volumes, including exception handling. A free portal and a paid platform do not necessarily deliver the same operational outcome.

For more tips on cutting costs and improving return management, check out our Forthroute homepage or explore our guide on best practices for multi-carrier returns automation.

Next, we’ll dive into actionable steps for setting up efficient workflows for in-store pickups and online returns.

How to Handle In-Store Pickup and Online Returns

Setting Up In-Store Pickup

Maintain accurate availability and collection instructions at each pickup location. Reconcile stock discrepancies before telling the customer that an item is ready.

Configure pickup instructions and supported notifications, then test them on the devices staff use. Mark an order ready only after the goods are prepared. Keep actual store opening hours clear to customers.

If a transfer is needed, use the configured Shopify admin workflow and record receipt before collection. Select suitable collection-level exclusions and processing times. Train staff to find the original order using supported order search rather than promising every identifier works on every screen.

Once you’ve optimized the pickup process, applying similar efficiency to your online returns can enhance your overall customer experience.

Making Online Returns Easier

Handling online returns effectively is just as important as managing in-store pickups. A branded self-service return portal makes the process straightforward for Shopify merchants. Adding a "Start a Return" link in your store's footer menu lets customers start a return themselves. They enter their Order ID and email, select the item, provide a reason (like "Too small"), and choose a resolution - refund or exchange. This reduces customer service enquiries and gives shoppers more control over their experience.

Offer a carrier QR label only where the actual account, route and drop-off service support it. Test approval rules and exceptions separately; a return value alone is not proof that a request should be automatically approved or refused.

If your return system can connect to your 3PL or warehouse management system, use that to keep inventory accurate once a return is inspected and restocked; if it cannot, keep a manual restock step in your warehouse process. To protect revenue, make an exchange easy to choose alongside the refund: if a customer returns a shirt due to sizing, offer the next size up to retain the sale.

For more tips on optimizing your return processes, check out the Forthroute homepage or explore their guide on best practices for multi-carrier returns automation.

Which POS System Is Right for Your Shopify Store

What to Consider Before Choosing

Picking the right POS system for your Shopify store comes down to a few key factors: cost, the workflow it covers, and your future growth plans. If you manage in-store pickups or handle online returns, look for a system that includes a custom self-service return feature. This reduces the need for customer support while giving shoppers the ability to process returns themselves. Check which resolutions each system can actually offer, since that decides how much revenue you retain. For more details, check out this guide on best practices for multi-carrier returns automation.

Convenience is another major factor. Some systems support printerless returns using QR codes where the carrier supports them, speeding up the process for both you and your customers. Some also connect to third-party logistics (3PL) or warehouse management systems to keep inventory updated; check what yours does. Many Shopify return apps are also easy to set up and don’t require any coding skills.

Keep pickup locations, opening hours, return terms and contact details accurate on the storefront.

Make those instructions readable and consistent across the product, checkout and policy pages. Clear public information does not guarantee a citation or recommendation by an AI service.

Evaluate Forthroute for the online return-request workflow described below.

Our Recommendation

Forthroute provides a branded Shopify return portal, configured approval rules, supported exchanges and optional prepaid labels. It has no software subscription and does not replace a POS. Check the supported workflow against your requirements before selecting it.

Forthroute stands out by focusing on revenue retention. It offers an exchange alongside each refund, with exchange incentives you configure, and lets you set approval rules (for example, marking returns under $50 approved). Optional prepaid labels are billed through Shopify at carrier cost converted to USD plus a 1% handling markup, with processing adjustments when included in the approved billing agreement; the total is rounded up to a US$0.10 increment. On the India Shiprocket lane, shipping leaves your own Shiprocket wallet and Forthroute charges US$0.10 through Shopify for each successful AWB, tracking number or label, even where no printable PDF is returned.

Select the returns app and POS subscription using verified requirements, costs and a representative test. This article does not establish that Forthroute is the best fit for most stores or that a paid returns plan is necessary for every multi-location business.

Want to simplify your returns process and keep more revenue? Start with Forthroute for free and turn returns into opportunities. Get started today.

Where the Free Option Runs Out

Separate capabilities by tool and plan. Forthroute does not manage retail staff or the counter. Shopify admin creates transfers; POS Pro supports fulfillment and receipt with the required permissions. Evaluate other advanced controls individually.

Forthroute is free returns software with no subscription and no monthly return limit, but it is Shopify-only, and it is software rather than a retail operation. It will not run your counter, manage staff permissions across stores, or replace a POS.

If you are running several locations with real in-store workflows, the premium tier is buying something Forthroute does not offer at any price.

FAQs

Can I do BOPIS and BORIS with a free POS setup?

Not with Forthroute alone, and it is worth being exact about why. Forthroute is returns software, not a point of sale: it does not run in-store pickup (BOPIS) or in-store returns (BORIS), and it does not move stock between locations. What it covers is the online half of the job:

  • A branded return portal with approval rules that clear the routine requests without an agent.
  • Printerless QR labels where the carrier supports them - on Forthroute, eligible UK Evri ParcelShop returns.
  • An exchange offered alongside the refund, so a return can keep the sale instead of reversing it.

All of this sits on top of Shopify, which stays the system of record for orders and stock. For the in-store half you still need Shopify POS or another retail system alongside it.

When does a paid returns plan pay off?

Use the provider’s current plan and a representative workload. Include setup, subscription, usage, labels and staff time, then compare the results with the alternative. A historical US$155 price or a high return count does not establish a positive return on investment.

A no-subscription portal may meet the online request requirements, but include shipping and handling costs and verify any missing features before deciding.

Upgrade when the verified benefit exceeds the added cost for your operation, with acceptable exception handling and support.

Does Shopify inventory update immediately after a return?

Return approval, refund issuance and restocking are separate actions. In Shopify POS, restocked goods normally go to the assigned location; Shopify documents an original-location restriction for goods fulfilled by a third-party logistics provider. Check the eligible location and quantities before confirming. Forthroute does not inspect or restock the goods.

Run Shopify returns in a branded portal you control — Forthroute, no subscription or monthly return limit.

Get Forthroute on the Shopify App Store →

Automation Ecommerce Returns

About the Author

Hylke Reitsma
Hylke Reitsma Founder & Supply Chain Specialist · Replit Race to Revenue Cohort #1

Hylke Reitsma is founder of Forthsuite and a supply chain specialist with 8+ years of hands-on experience at Shell, Verisure, and Stryker. He holds an MSc in Supply Chain Management from the University of Groningen and writes practical guides to help e-commerce teams run leaner, faster supply chains. Selected by Replit as 1 of 20 founders for the inaugural Race to Revenue Cohort #1 (2026) and certified as a Replit Platform Builder.

LinkedIn
← Back to Blog

Make returns a competitive advantage

No software subscription or monthly return limit; optional platform prepaid labels are billed separately.

Install Free