← Back to Blog
Operator Research

Returns Management: What Operators Said

This page presents two operator accounts: one on supplier checks, one on cash-on-delivery and return-to-origin costs. Each theme has one direct respondent; these accounts are not a Shopify return-rate benchmark or evidence of a typical budget. Forthroute provides a returns portal, approval rules, exchange support and merchant-issued refunds.

By Hylke Reitsma · Founder & Supply Chain Specialist · Replit Race to Revenue Cohort #1

Hylke Reitsma is founder of Forthsuite and a supply chain specialist with 8+ years of hands-on experience at Shell, Verisure, and Stryker. He holds an MSc in Supply Chain Management from the University of Groningen and writes practical guides to help e-commerce teams run leaner, faster supply chains. Selected by Replit as 1 of 20 founders for the inaugural Race to Revenue Cohort #1 (2026) and certified as a Replit Platform Builder.

10 min read
Circular arrows connect packaged boxes on conveyor belts with return labels flowing back through an organized courier system
In this article

TL;DR: This page presents two operator accounts: one on supplier checks, one on cash-on-delivery and return-to-origin costs. Each theme has one direct respondent; these accounts are not a Shopify returns-management benchmark or evidence of a typical budget. Forthroute provides a returns portal, approval rules, exchange support and merchant-issued refunds.

Last updated: November 2026

April 2026 — primary research, on the record. Part of our 13-operator research series.

TL;DR — what operators told us

Returns research themes and direct respondent counts
Theme Operators speaking directly Evidence scope
Reverse logistics today 1 of 2 Manual supplier/operational checks in the current workflow.
RMA workflow gaps 1 of 2 Return-to-origin severity and financial impact.
Refund-versus-restock economics 1 of 2 Cash-on-delivery constraints and accepted RTO exposure.
  • Reverse logistics today. One account describes supplier checks and return-policy questions.
  • RMA workflow gaps. One account describes failed delivery and return-to-origin costs.
  • Refund-vs-restock economics. The COD account discusses payment choices and RTO exposure, not a measured refund-versus-restock comparison.
  • Treat these as questions to investigate in your own operation, with a defined order cohort and costs for each outcome.

What this is

This is the forthroute cut of our 13-operator research conversations: every quote below comes from a Shopify or Amazon merchant who explicitly raised this product area as a live pain point. Forthroute is returns and RMA management for Shopify — refund, exchange and reverse-logistics tooling for the leakage operators describe below.

See the master research piece for the cross-product picture.

Who we talked to about this

a multi-store dropshipping operator

Multi-store dropship operator — Operator · cosmetics · US

“When onboarding a new supplier I always test them: small test order (sometimes payment on delivery or 50% deposit), check quality, delivery time, and return/refund policy. The three things I care about most are: Product…”

a freelance Shopify operator

Freelance Shopify operator — Freelance Shopify operator (RTO/COD specialist) · ecommerce services · IN

“50–60% of orders become RTO. Prepaid to COD ratio is roughly 1:9 (only 10% prepaid). When a customer refuses the package, the business pays the full shipping cost both ways + lost ad spend + order management cost.”

Reverse logistics today

One of the two accounts discusses supplier checks. The quotation below is the account presented on this page.

“When onboarding a new supplier I always test them: small test order (sometimes payment on delivery or 50% deposit), check quality, delivery time, and return/refund policy. The three things I care about most are: Product quality, Delivery speed / reliability, Return & refund policy”

— a multi-store dropshipping operator

Context: The account describes an existing supplier-check process: a small test order, quality, delivery and return-policy checks. It does not measure outcomes or interest in a paid tool.

Evidence scope: One supplier-check account. Compare the process with your own product, supplier and destination requirements.

RMA workflow gaps

One of the two accounts discusses return-to-origin. The quotation below is the respondent’s description of that operation.

“50–60% of orders become RTO. Prepaid to COD ratio is roughly 1:9 (only 10% prepaid). When a customer refuses the package, the business pays the full shipping cost both ways + lost ad spend + order management cost.”

— a freelance Shopify operator

Context: The respondent reports RTO percentages and a prepaid/COD mix. This page provides no order cohort, measurement period or independently checked denominator for those percentages.

To assess your own RTO exposure, count failed deliveries in a defined shipped-order cohort and separate outbound shipping, return shipping, advertising and handling costs. A customer return after delivery is a different event.

Refund-vs-restock economics

The same COD/RTO respondent discusses payment choices. This is another statement from that account, not an additional respondent.

“Businesses usually just stop selling high-RTO products and switch to new ones, but you can't get below ~30% RTO in India if you offer COD. Without COD option, orders drop by ~70%.”

— a freelance Shopify operator

Context: The 30% and 70% figures are the respondent’s estimates. They do not establish a national floor, make COD mandatory or prove what would happen if another merchant removed COD.

Assess payment choices using your own comparable cohorts. Track delivery outcomes, cancellations, purchase conversion and contribution margin alongside order count.

What each operator told us, in one line

The following summary refers to the COD/RTO account; it is not a separate respondent.

  • a freelance Shopify operator, Freelance Shopify operator (RTO/COD specialist) of Freelance Shopify operator: Extremely high Return-to-Origin (RTO) rates due to Cash on Delivery payment method

What they’re using today

These two accounts describe different tooling setups. The lists below are reported working practices, not performance benchmarks or endorsements of return restrictions.

  • a multi-store dropshipping operator, Operator of Multi-store dropship operator: Google Sheets for inventory tracking with manual thresholds (50% and 70%); Google Drive for images and documents; WhatsApp for supplier communication (3-4 China, 2 US suppliers); UPS for logistics integration; DSers for dropshipping and supplier integration.
  • a freelance Shopify operator, Freelance Shopify operator (RTO/COD specialist) of Freelance Shopify operator: NDR (Non-Delivery Report) system from some courier partners requiring OTP confirmation; Manual product switching strategy (discontinuing high-RTO products); Manual tracking of RTO data via courier dashboards; Location-based selling restrictions; COD option management (the respondent estimated a 70% order drop; this is not a tested causal result here).

A spreadsheet appearing in a tool list does not by itself show that an end-to-end product is missing. Identify the manual task, its time and error costs, and whether existing tools can handle it.

How they’re thinking about budget

Neither entry supplies a budget range. The following notes record that gap; they do not establish a willingness-to-pay ceiling or a purchase commitment.

  • a multi-store dropshipping operator, Operator of Multi-store dropship operator: Budget range not provided in this published account.
  • a freelance Shopify operator, Freelance Shopify operator (RTO/COD specialist) of Freelance Shopify operator: Budget range not provided in this published account.

Follow-up questions should establish current costs, the decision-maker, alternatives and whether a priced offer was accepted. Two unspecified budgets are not price validation.

What this means for your stack

Forthroute manages Shopify return requests, merchant-issued refunds, exchange support and return-leg tracking. Assess those functions against your workflow; this interview material does not show that the app reduces COD refusals or carrier failures. See the Forthroute product page.

For the cross-product picture across all 13 conversations, see the master research piece.

Methodology

Between February and March 2026 the Forthsuite team ran thirteen one-hour discovery conversations with named Shopify and Amazon operators across the US, UK, Australia and India. Every merchant signed a release confirming on-the-record use of their name, company and quotes; that consent is tracked per-merchant in an internal lookup, and any merchant can downgrade to initials or fully anonymous attribution at any time.

Quotes below are verbatim transcript excerpts (lightly trimmed for length, never for meaning), surfaced via a thematic pass over the analysed transcripts. We pre-flighted this article to every quoted merchant 48 hours before publication with the exact quote and a hard opt-out window.

How to read these quotes

Three points of method that matter for how you weight what you just read. First, every quote comes from a real operator we spoke to; operators who did not agree to be named are described by role. We have not paraphrased anyone, and we do not use composite personas.

Second, every quote is presented inside the conversational context that prompted it — the significance field for key quotes and the description field for pain points are kept verbatim in the metadata behind this page so that future writers cannot drift the meaning. Third, where an operator opted for initials-only or anonymous attribution, we honour that here in the same way we did at the top of the funnel; the source evidence does not change, only the attribution string does.

The corollary is that "we did not pull a verbatim quote into this section" means exactly that — not a missing data point, but a missing on-the-record permission to publish a specific operator’s words in that specific cut. As we add merchants whose conversations speak directly to the sub-theme, those sections fill in.

What we’ll publish next on this theme

We are actively expanding the forthroute interview corpus. The next round of conversations is targeted at operators with active programmes in this exact area — so every new merchant we add will speak directly to returns management rather than as an aside.

Specifically we are looking for two profiles: one, operators who have rebuilt this part of their stack in the last twelve months and can speak to the before-and-after; two, operators who have evaluated the available tools and consciously chosen to keep their current spreadsheet-based workflow, and can articulate the gap that kept them there.

If you run a Shopify or Amazon brand that has wrestled with this part of the operation, we would value a 45-minute on-the-record conversation. The format mirrors the thirteen we have already shipped: a transcribed call, your verbatim quotes shown back to you 48 hours before publication, and a hard opt-out window. We do not lead with a product pitch — the pitch, if any, comes after the research conversation, and only with explicit permission. Get in touch.

For the pillars that already cleared the 3-operator floor and read in full today, see the master research piece and the companion deep dives linked from it. The pattern across all five product areas is the same: operators want fewer tools, tighter integration between the ones they keep, and a higher bar of evidence before they swap out a workflow they have already battle-tested. The verbatim quotes above are how we are evidencing that shape ourselves.

Run Shopify returns in a branded portal you control — Forthroute, no subscription or monthly return limit.

Get Forthroute on the Shopify App Store →

Frequently Asked Questions

What 2 operators told us about returns management and the RMA workflow (starter edition)?

This page presents two operator accounts: one on supplier checks, one on cash-on-delivery and return-to-origin costs. Each theme has one direct respondent; these accounts are not a Shopify return-rate benchmark or evidence of a typical budget. Forthroute provides a returns portal, approval rules, exchange support and merchant-issued refunds.

Operator Research Shopify Primary Research Forthroute

About the Author

Hylke Reitsma
Hylke Reitsma Founder & Supply Chain Specialist · Replit Race to Revenue Cohort #1

Hylke Reitsma is founder of Forthsuite and a supply chain specialist with 8+ years of hands-on experience at Shell, Verisure, and Stryker. He holds an MSc in Supply Chain Management from the University of Groningen and writes practical guides to help e-commerce teams run leaner, faster supply chains. Selected by Replit as 1 of 20 founders for the inaugural Race to Revenue Cohort #1 (2026) and certified as a Replit Platform Builder.

LinkedIn
← Back to Blog

Make returns a competitive advantage

No software subscription or monthly return limit; optional platform prepaid labels are billed separately.

Install Free